The persistent objector rule is said to provide states with an ‘escape hatch’ from the otherwise universal binding force of customary international law. It provides that if a state persistently objects to a newly emerging norm of customary international law during the formation of that norm, then the objecting state is exempt from the norm once it crystallises into law. The conceptual role of the rule may be interpreted as straightforward: to preserve the fundamentalist positivist notion that any norm of international law can only bind a state that has consented to be bound by it. In reality, however, numerous unanswered questions exist about the way that it works in practice.
Through focused analysis of state practice, this monograph provides a detailed understanding of how the rule emerged and operates, how it should be conceptualised, and what its implications are for the binding nature of customary international law. It argues that the persistent objector rule ultimately has an important role to play in the mixture of consent and consensus that underpins international law.
Table of Contents
Foreword, Sir Michael Wood
Introduction
Part 1: The Origin and Legal Source of the Persistent Objector Rule
1. The History and Emergence of the Persistent Objector Rule
2. The Persistent Objector Rule in Case Law and State Practice Post-1945
Part 2: The Criteria for the Operation of the Persistent Objector Rule
3. The Objection Criterion
4. The Persistence Criterion
5. The Consistency Criterion
6. The Timeliness Criterion
Part 3: The Limitations and Role of the Persistent Objector Rule
7. Peremptory Norms and Persistent Objection
8. Maintaining Exemption: ‘Fundamental’ Norms and Extra Legal Factors
9. The Role and Value of the Persistent Objector Rule
Conclusion
Author Information
James A. Green, Professor of Public International Law, University of Reading
James A. Green is Professor of Public International Law at the University of Reading, where he has been a member of staff since 2006. He obtained his doctorate from the University of Nottingham and, in 2005, was a visiting research scholar at the University of Michigan. His primary research interests are the international law on the use of force, particularly self-defence, and the formation of customary international law.
Contributors:
Sir Michael Wood
Reviews and Awards
Winner of the 2017 ESIL Book Prize
